Google Android T-Mobile G1 launch event

If you're new here, you may want to subscribe to my Twitter stream or my RSS feed. Thanks for visiting!

I had the chance to attend this. You can hear me ask a question (“how really locked is sim-locked?”) here at 36:30 http://www.t-mobileg1.com/g1-announcement.aspx

My question stems from the big obvious drawback to “open” here: that as with the iPhone, this product is stuck to one carrier. However, once the platform actually goes open source, we could look forward to seeing entire new devices that work on other networks. Engadget talks a bit more about this: they expanded upon my question in private afterwards, and got a more encouraging answer. I’m still dubious as to how other carriers may take to this or fight it, but this is a big start.

Also to note: The word “iPhone” must be taboo amongst the companies involved. In the response to my question, where I mention iPhone by name, he says “the device you mention”. :)

Re the device itself, I don’t have much more than what’s already been said. I’m definitely impressed that for something that came out so relatively quickly, and it being just the 1.0 version, it’s a very slick-looking and -feeling gadget. Not quite as sexy as iPhone’s screen and pinch functions, but it’s close and adds a real keyboard.

Also, re core PIM apps and messaging: At the moment, I love Windows Mobile, mostly because since I’m already bought into the Microsoft vertical (Exchange), it’s a seamless experience. Similarly, the G1 launches really optimized around gmail, gCal, etc, and for now your experience will likely be dictated by how tied your life is tied to the Google vertical. But give it a chance to launch and attract some developers (Good Technology-type outfits, and indy developers) to write Exchange clients etc, and this platform could be promising long-term.

  • YYQ

    Apple’s brand power is definitely huge and G1 doesn’t offer attractive pricing as for both the device and plans. Also think about customers stucked with 2yr plans with other carriers. T-mobile seems not to have a good reputation in New York…

    http://www.marketwatch.com/news/story/google-phone-nice-not-game-changer/story.aspx?guid=%7BA865281D%2DF697%2D4710%2D9D84%2DBEE3A48BF745%7D&siteid=yhoof

  • YYQ

    Apple’s brand power is definitely huge and G1 doesn’t offer attractive pricing as for both the device and plans. Also think about customers stucked with 2yr plans with other carriers. T-mobile seems not to have a good reputation in New York…

    http://www.marketwatch.com/news/story/google-phone-nice-not-game-changer/story.aspx?guid=%7BA865281D%2DF697%2D4710%2D9D84%2DBEE3A48BF745%7D&siteid=yhoof

  • http://kenberger.com Ken Berger

    I’d agree w/ the statement re T-Mobile in NY.

    To Google’s credit, it seems clear they really want to be as ‘open’ as possible, from all angles, including w/ regard to networks. But at least in today’s landscape, they had to pick a carrier, so the close deal w/ T-Mo was a necessary evil.

    Will future wider networks such as WiMax help things? We’ll see.

  • http://kenberger.com Ken Berger

    I’d agree w/ the statement re T-Mobile in NY.

    To Google’s credit, it seems clear they really want to be as ‘open’ as possible, from all angles, including w/ regard to networks. But at least in today’s landscape, they had to pick a carrier, so the close deal w/ T-Mo was a necessary evil.

    Will future wider networks such as WiMax help things? We’ll see.

blog comments powered by Disqus